Skip to content

Turkey Day Out

2008 November 17
by Guy

We are seriously considering going out for Thanksgiving dinner this year. We saw the Brewer’s Alley buffet, but are there any others out there? Any suggestions?

~Guy~

29 Responses leave one →
  1. November 17, 2008

    Mealey’s is having a buffet:
    http://mealeysrestaurant.com/__calendar/calendar.pl

    So is The Cracked Claw:
    http://www.thecrackedclaw.net/

    I’ll keep watching out for others but I’m also curious what others are doing.

  2. November 17, 2008

    My family and I had Thanksgiving dinner at South Mountain Inn a couple of years ago and it was enjoyed it very much. There was no buffet, but the food was excellent. My parents also really got a kick out of the glass-walled dining room.

    http://www.oldsouthmountaininn.com/

    • kshaskins permalink
      November 7, 2011

      South Mountain Inn is extremely expensive!

  3. November 17, 2008

    We went to Comus Inn last year. Pretty good buffet, a little pricey….

  4. November 17, 2008

    G. Hunters also has a turkey day menu:

    Menu

    Slow Cooked Hereford Prime Rib Au Jus
    Roasted Turkey with Kölsch Gravy
    Dorsey’s Honey Ham
    Maple Roasted Canadian Coldwater Salmon with Citrus Butter

    Drunken Port Wine Cranberries
    Haricot Vert & Oyster Mushroom Casserole
    Five Cheese Macaroni Gratin
    Rosemary Whipped Potatoes
    Butternut Squash Risotto
    Fresh Steamed Vegetable Bouquet

    Peel & Eat Shrimp
    Cold Smoked PEI Mussels
    Local Chesapeake Oysters

    *Menu includes non alcoholic beverage, tax and gratuity. $28 per adult, $15 per child age 10 and older.

  5. November 17, 2008

    Beleive it or not, one year i went to the American Legion on thomas Johson Drive and it was EXCELLENT! It was also inexpensive.

  6. Matthew permalink
    November 17, 2008

    We found G Hunter’s Thanksgiving buffet two years ago far better than Mealey’s last year. Mealey’s (my sister’s choice) served a huge buffet, but G Hunter’s quality was outstanding.

    Other G Hunter plusses: Easy access. E-Z free parking. Nice, non-defeaning ambiance. And a great view of the golf course.

  7. Jon permalink
    November 17, 2008

    I haven’t done the G. Hunter’s Thanksgiving buffet but, in general, my wife and I are huge fans of their menu. I can’t see you going wrong there.

  8. Matthew permalink
    November 18, 2008

    I got part of that wrong. G Hunter’s didn’t have a buffet. They serve a Thanksgiving dinner. Mealey’s had the buffet, and it just didn’t wow me.

  9. Denman permalink
    November 18, 2008

    Going out to dinner on holidays is verboten around our house. Even a normal restaurants have too many people, too loud, over stressed help etc. etc.. Holidays are worse. Maybe it’s because I spent a number of holidays working in a restaurant when I was in high school (the Blue and Grey room at the old Francis Scott Key Hotel, pretty much the high end restaurant in Fredneck in it’s day) It is also difficult to visit with family in a restaurant. However, to each their own. Does look like a nice menu at G. Hunters though. However living downtown, and because I enjoy there food, if I was going out it I would likely head for Brewer’s Alley, their menu looks great.

  10. November 18, 2008

    I worked at Brewers and I would never recommend anyone eat there. The kitchen is absolutely filthy and I left shortly after arriving. I know of several people who have gotten food poisoning from there.

  11. November 18, 2008

    Did you ever consider ordering a take out thanksgiving dinner? There are a lot of restaurants that do this.

    • Stacey permalink
      November 8, 2009

      Hi! I’m looking to do Thanksgiving dinner different this year; alittle easier… What restaurants do take out? I know grocery stores offer this. Thanks for your suggestion, I look forward to checking this out.

    • November 8, 2010

      could you tell me who does carry out for thanksgiving dinner?

      • November 8, 2010

        Maybe honey baked ham on 40

      • kshaskins permalink
        November 7, 2011

        I is over kill for to cook a huge meal for just 2 people. You eat the same ole food for 4 days and then can’t stand it any more. So carry out Thanksgiving is ok.

  12. Matthew permalink
    November 18, 2008

    Disclaimer: I am not affiliated with G Hunters in any way.

    Denman, our experience at G Hunters was exceptional. We arrived at 2 to 2:30 p.m., when few of the tables were taken. It was serene inside and beautiful outside the oversized windows.

    Our turkey was moist and flavorful, which isn’t easy to pull off. Great food, ample servings, and excellent waiters made for a memorable afternoon. Mealey’s, by contrast, wasn’t that great. Not bad, just not a good value.

    Were we eating out this Thanksgiving, G Hunters would be our #1 choice in Frederick County.

  13. BabyDoe permalink
    November 20, 2008

    If you don’t mind driving to Old Town Alexandria I highly recommend Bastille’s prix fixe Thanksgiving dinner (details below). This is my favorite restaurant in the MD-DC-VA-WV area. Yes, it is a bit of a drive from where I live in Westminster, but it is ALWAYS worth it. I eat there as often as possible when I am in that area. I just had a marvelous brunch there last Sunday, and I have reservations for Thanksgiving. It is a terrific bargain at $49. Among the niceties you can expect are wine offerings by the glass and the half-glass…PERFECT for a multi-course dinner!
    Happy Thanksgiving

    Thursday, November 27th 2008
    Served from 5:00 to 9:30

    Dinner prix fixe: $49
    (Taxes & gratuities not included)

    Soup or salad
    Roasted Butternut squash chowder
    with crispy onions and pancetta

    Goat cheese cromesqui, baby frisee, dates,
    Toasted hazelnuts, pancetta vinaigrette

    Truffled duck liver mousse on “Pain d’Epices”, Honey-spiced bread
    Baby spinach, balsamic vinaigrette

    Entrees
    Roasted Guinea Hen, cranberry chutney, Sage-Chestnut stuffing,
    Sweet potato gratin, sautéed greens

    Grass-Fed Beef Filet-Mignon, Long pepper sauce, cranberry chutney
    Celeriac-parsnip puree, wild mushrooms and organic carrots

    Pan-roasted Halibut filet, Tarragon-mushroom cream sauce
    Green lentils and baby carrots

    Vegetarian options upon requests

    *Optional Cheese Course: (Add $12)
    Trio of Artisanal cheeses with house made condiments
    (If you wish to have cheese instead of dessert, add $5)

    Desserts
    Pumpkin Napoleon

    Apple strudel

    Warm Valrhona Manjari chocolate Truffle cake

    Chef / Owners Christophe & Michelle Poteaux
    1201 N. Royal Street, Alexandria, VA 22315 – Tel: 703-519-3776
    http://www.bastillerestaurant.com

  14. Frederick Fan permalink
    November 23, 2008

    Cracked Claw’s Thanksgiving menu sounded like a good deal to us, at $20. So we’re going to give it a try.

  15. December 8, 2008

    Thanks for the advice! I totally forgot to let you all know that we went to G. Hunters and had a very nice meal. Good service and eats.

  16. FrederickFan permalink
    December 10, 2008

    While I won’t claim that Cracked Claw’s food matched up to the sophistication of the menu at, say, G. Hunters (but we’re also talking $20 vs. $49) , nonetheless we found it tasty buffet fare and a great value.

    The buffet included more items than were listed on the already lengthy menu. My only complaint was with the turkey (I know, what should have been the “centerpiece” of the whole spread), which I found somewhat tough and hard to cut (wondered if it may have been a bit undercooked). BUT the chicken, fish, beef, ham, pasta, etc., provided plenty of satisfying alternatives.

  17. Liz permalink*
    November 8, 2011

    It’s interesting and sad how many restaurants mentioned in the comments here no longer exist.

  18. Patricia permalink
    November 8, 2011

    I was thinking the same thing, Liz! I just found this article today as I was searching for ready made Thanksgiving meals in Frederick.

    • FrederickFan permalink
      November 9, 2011

      I was hoping there would be a few suggestions here for ready-made Thanksgiving meals, or restaurants serving Thanksgiving dinner (I’m aware of Brewer’s Alley, but beyond that?). I, too, don’t know what to make of the fact that so many places mentioned here in the past no longer exist.

      • JJP permalink
        November 9, 2011

        We were at LJs in Hagerstown for dinner last week and they had a flyer announcing take-out Thanksgiving dinner. I don’t have the particulars and they haven’t posted them to their web-site yet. Their food is very good. If interested, you may want to give them a call – (301) 739-7990.

        JJP

  19. Gypsy permalink
    November 9, 2011

    Wegmans ad in today’s paper shows a full meal that you can buy from them.

  20. FrederickFan permalink
    November 12, 2011

    Thx. for the Thanksgiving takeout or restaurant suggestions!

  21. Susie permalink
    November 17, 2011

    If you are looking to order a “traditional” Thanksgiving meal to bring home and serve, I would suggest you try Bob Evans! The food is good and the price is reasonable. My family and I have order their “Farmer’s Feast” for the past 2 years and were very pleased.

Trackbacks and Pingbacks

  1. Thanksgiving out/2009 « Frederick Maryland Online

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS